Imagine you’re a juror about to hear an opening statement. The plaintiff’s lawyer stands up and says the following:
There are seven important issues in this case. The first issue is whether the stock issued in June 1973 by Mr. Jones was properly registered.
Now imagine another courtroom. This time, the lawyer starts like this:
The story begins three years ago today. Four men were sitting around a table. One of them is here. One of them is there. The other two wouldn’t come to testify. They were discussing a new share of stock. The ownership of the company was at stake.
These dueling examples are courtesy of Fred Bartlit, one of the most in-demand business trial lawyers in the nation. How do you tell an effective story even when your material is dry or complex? “You don’t tell [the jurors] what to decide,” Bartlit says. “[A]s they hear the story, conclusions emerge in their minds.”
How to Start a Statement of Facts: Set the Stage and Sound Your Theme
Think of the opening scene in a favorite film. Sure, some films start with a character in mid-conversation. But more typically, the camera pans over a grassy meadow or a crowded urban bar. Such images cue you in on what kind of story you’re about to hear, and arouse your curiosity about what will happen next.
In the brief-writing world, you probably can’t start your fact sections with an Oscar-worthy scene-setting shot. But you can still draw your readers in.
Joshua Rosenkranz, Facebook, Inc. v. ConnectU, Inc.
The plotline of this controversy is all too familiar: Wunderkind entrepreneur conceives of a transformative business and propels it to a meteoric success, but failed rivals insist they thought up the idea first and demand all the profits.
How could you not sympathize with young Mr. Zuckerberg? Word choice makes all the difference here.
Start your own fact sections, then, with more “it was the best of times, it was the worst of times” and less “it was a dark and stormy night.”
How to Handle Bad Facts in a Brief: Concede Them, but Put Them in Context
“The facts give the fix,” said the late D.C. Circuit Chief Judge Patricia Wald. “[S]pend time amassing them in a compelling way for your side but do not omit the ones that go the other way. Tackle these uncooperative facts and put them in perspective.”
Ted Olson uses a classic bad-fact strategy in his winning brief in Citizens United: starting a sentence with “although” to subordinate the bad fact to its more favorable context:
Citizens United v. FEC
In mid-2007, Citizens United began production of Hillary: The Movie, a biographical documentary about Senator Hillary Clinton, who was then a candidate to become the Democratic Party’s nominee for President. Although Senator Clinton’s candidacy was the backdrop for the 90-minute documentary, neither the movie’s narrator nor any of the individuals interviewed during the movie expressly advocated her election or defeat as President.
Follow Olson’s lead by including an “Although” sentence the next time you’re walking a tightrope in your own fact section.
How to Make Facts Persuasive Without Arguing: Let Choice Details Speak for Themselves
Unfortunately, most litigators subscribe to the “tell ’em he was a conspicuous consumer” school of writing. Fact sections are often riddled with such conclusions as “Plaintiff has engaged in dilatory tactics” and “Defendant has at all times acted with the utmost candor” and “Defendant had a terrible childhood.”
Instead, the facts in a brief should read like narrative nonfiction, a bit like something you’d read in The Atlantic or The New Yorker.
A woman named Lois Davis complained to the EEOC after her state-government employer punished her for reporting sexual harassment at work. While the complaint was pending, Davis’s supervisor told her to report to work on a Sunday, insisting that she skip church to do so. Davis found someone to cover her shift, went to church, and was fired the next day.
Davis sued. Although the appeal turned on a dry legal question about Title VII’s pre-suit filing requirements, the attorneys begin by highlighting Davis’s piety. Swept by this novelistic prose, we draw our own conclusion that Davis should not have been punished for attending church:
Brian Fletcher, Pamela Karlan, Thomas Wright, Russell Hollenbeck, and Raffi Melkonian, Fort Bend County v. Davis
Ms. Davis is a devout Christian. An active member of her church, she has long attended 8:00 AM and 10:00 AM services every Sunday. She also attends Tuesday-night Bible studies and plays an important role in the church’s administration. All of those actions are directly motivated and required by Ms. Davis’s personal religious faith.
Resist the litigator’s urge to characterize facts and tell the court what they mean. Why burst any illusion that you’re an honest broker trying to give a fair account of the events in question? Devote your energies instead to combing through the record in search of facts so clear and strong that they make your case on their own.
Emphasis added in excerpts
.png)


.png)